Kidney Hill & the Ongoing Saga

Over the past two weeks the, weekly column of Ardeshir Cowasjee appearing in DAWN has been about a very controversial issue which highlights the battle between the money hungry local government and the citizens of Karachi. His article has been pleading to expose the issue of the Kidney Hill, a 62-acre park between Karsaz Road and Shaheed-e-Millat. This 62 acre piece of land is officially designated a park but has been within the cross hairs of the land developers for sometime including those individuals who will benefit by a healthy lubrication of wealth once this area becomes developable.

The legal battle started with a number of petitioners, many of which were local residents from the neighboring area but sadly over the few weeks these people were forced to withdraw their cases as they were being threatened form a number of sources, leaving Shehri alone to fight the battle. Shehri is not a new name for Karachi and have to its credit fought a number of issues for Karachi against the greedy developers. What has really shocked me was the fact that the mafia was finally able to sneak under their skin as well and threatened them with dire circumstances. There is no doubt that Shehri has been over the many years must have taken its share of threatening hone calls from this ruthless mafia, but for them to finally succumb to a threatening phone call must indeed be of a grave concern. I quote Cowasjee as he writes about the issue today.

After the governor’s meeting on Thursday, Amber Alibhai, Shehri’s general secretary, again received a “threatening” phone call. This time, the issuer of threats related all that had transpired at the governor’s meeting, and told Amber that he could e-mail to her photographs of her children and tell her exactly what they did where and when. She was told to expect the “worst” if the petition was not withdrawn from the court.

Thereupon the Shehri office-bearers hurriedly met and instructed their lawyer, Barrister Mohammad Gilbert Naimur Rahman, as follows:

“Re: Withdrawal of Kidney Hill Case, CP 160/2007. After much deliberation, we, the managing committee members, are instructing you to withdraw the above case. The reasons are threats of kidnapping and murder made to us and our families, involvement of false cases instituted on 22 February 2007 in the lower court, the day the threatening calls began. We have been advised by all our well-wishers that it is simply impossible to stop these threats from being carried out. Too much money is involved in this deal. We do not wish to jeopardize our families and their lives. Thank you for your continued support.”

It is signed by Mrs Amber Alibhai, Roland de Souza, chairperson, Dr Syed Raza Ali Gardezi, vice chairperson and Khatib Ahmed, member – all of Shehri-CBE. – DAWN Cowasjee 4th March 2006

To read the entire saga you can read all of Cowasjee’s articles in Dawn from Feb 18, Feb 25 & today March 4th

It is simply shocking that from a city of 13 millions we can only find Shehri (Mrs Amber AliBhai and Roland de Souza, Dr. Syed Raza Gandezi & Khatib Ahmed) to stand up against this ruthless mafia, we should all be ashamed of ourselves, it is time to spread the word, come forth and lets defend our city. I truly believe we can be a voice to reckon with but we must stand up for our city.

I seriously feel the urge to do something and support this issue of Karachi, hence I issue out a public call to Karachiites to come forth and join hands to stand up for their city. Am I alone in this battle or do I hear a rally call for people willing to step up for Karachi!!!!!

8 Comments so far

  1. Teeth Maestro (unregistered) on March 4th, 2007 @ 6:14 pm
  2. karachiite (unregistered) on March 4th, 2007 @ 6:55 pm

    Who exactly are the members of this ‘mafia’ that is being talked about? The best way to neutralize them is to publicly name the criminals who are threatening people. Exposing them is the best policy.

    And yes, Karachi needs all the parks that it can get. This city is a concrete jungle with barely any green space. So this issue is worth fighting over.

  3. lost_in_the_maze (unregistered) on March 4th, 2007 @ 6:57 pm

    Count me in for the march….

  4. MB (unregistered) on March 4th, 2007 @ 7:07 pm

    Is there anyway our concerned can be conveyed to them. My latest post too was related to the same issue dude. Sure those who are concerned about their city are together. And please if anyone of you has the video recording of Arif Hassan’s interview to Anwar Maqsood on ARY ONE WORLD let me know. Its a must watch interview for Karachiites. The name of the program is AM at 8PM

    Someone please upload it if anyone has its copy. Also if anyone can have the video of interview of HAMID MAKER from The Helpline Trust. That interview is also important. We need to spread the word and let citizens know what are our rights. HAMID MAKER has discussed many important issues regarding consumer rights and his help line trust in that interview. Both were show on ARY ONE WORLD’s morning program “Bakhabar savera”

    @TM is there anyway you can get those videos?

  5. MB (unregistered) on March 4th, 2007 @ 7:10 pm

    Consider this We can shout, but what chance hope ? as in line with your post.

  6. naveed (unregistered) on March 5th, 2007 @ 1:26 am

    As always there’s another side of the story as well.
    The matter is still in court so I don’t think the law allows anyone to politicise a case thats sub-judice.

    Why not let the court decide who is right.

  7. MB (unregistered) on March 5th, 2007 @ 7:27 am


    As is the habit of our readers, you didnot read his artile properly i guess. He himself has mentioned this letter & just in case you want to same time, its the last para in his article.

    And also, please keep in mind this may be on incident but the issue more than this one case. Its the issue of whole Karachi land being hijacked by builders + building authorities + gov all for money and greed. Development was the best of drama they could come up with so the public is being duped.

  8. MB (unregistered) on March 5th, 2007 @ 11:25 am

    save** time

Terms of use | Privacy Policy | Content: Creative Commons | Site and Design © 2009 | Metroblogging ® and Metblogs ® are registered trademarks of Bode Media, Inc.